Engaging the culture by challenging the status quo
The New York Beacon recently reported on a meeting between Microsoft and members of NNPA (National Newspapers Publishers Association). I thought that the article did a pretty good job representing both sides of this issue.
Excerpt 1
Speaking heatedly in the large auditorium, Eubanks said that the Black Press gets the “crumbs†when it comes to advertising dollars compared to White newspapers and that the chances of other Black-owned newspapers getting the company’s advertising are slim.
“I’m in Seattle, I’m right in your market and I can’t even get the time of day. So God knows how these other publishers who are outside your market are going to reach Microsoft,†said Eubanks.
Excerpt 2
Smith’s sentiments were reaffirmed by Ken Smikle, founder and president of Target Market News. Smikle later told publishers in a workshop called “The African-American Market” that a 21st Century advertising market is more digital, more numbers-oriented and far more technical.
However, some publishers rejected Smikle’s message, contending that after realizing that even when they had the data, advertising executives still do not give them the time of day.
“Data does not necessarily do the deal,†said James Washington, publisher of the Dallas Weekly. “Doing business with us is new; we have to show our value beyond readership and circulation.â€Â
But, Terry Artis of Limelight newspaper in St. Louis agrees that the Black Press must make some change in its advertising strategies: “They don’t want to hear ‘its good for the community’ anymore; they want a win-win situation.â€Â
I had a recent exchange with reader MIB on this issue that you may find interesting. I see this as a sad move by the Black press to excuse their low readership (mind you, most newspapers around the country are also losing readership–mainly due to the Internet) by slamming anyone for not advertising in BLACK newspapers. MIB on the other hand does not see it that way. In any event, I think that this is a topic worthy of discussion for anybody interested in Black media.
Sphere: Related Content
You are viewing a mobilized version of this site...
View original page here
No Responses to A Microsoft Exchange
MIB
July 3rd, 2007 at 6:14 am
I think this statement from Microsoft’s Jose Pinero effectively sums my point on corporate America and advertising in Black media:
“To be very frank [convincing Microsoft to buy ads in Black media is] a challenge. Part of the issue is ignorance and part of the issue is they think that, ‘Hey if we just put our advertising in USA Today, it reaches everybody.”
Now, if as Terry Artis insinuated, ad reps from Black media and ad agencies are pitching would-be advertisers that buys function as the equivalent of charitable donations to the Black community, then I’d be the first person to acknowledge the error in strategy. And perhaps in some ways, subtly, reps from Black media are emphasizing this point. My first hand experience with Black media suggests otherwise, though.
Corporate America is just starting to realize the economic potential of the Af-Am market, but lacks an understanding of the subculture that’s critical to marketing success. Hence, the value in Black-owned ad agencies like R.J. Dale and Lattimer Moffitt.